Elmira: A publisher quits at an unusually young age

And this one was publisher over two Gannett papers in New York. Monte Trammer (left) had run the Star-Gazette in Elmira — Gannett’s first newspaper — since 1999, and the Ithaca Journal since last year.

Replacing Trammer: Sherman Bodner, who is the top executive of Gannett’s Central New York newspapers group. In addition to Elmira and Ithaca, the group includes the Press & Sun Bulletin in Binghamton. Central New York announced a big work consolidation in July.

Trammer, one of Gannett’s few minority publishers, is only 57, according to a Star-Gazette story yesterday that says his last day will be Saturday. His departure at such a relatively young age led some readers here to wonder whether he jumped — or was pushed. “Is this voluntary?” Anonymous@3:17 p.m. asked in yesterday’s Real Time Comments. “Will this be the trend, allowing publishers to retire versus getting canned? Just seems to me there is more to this story. Anyone have the inside track here?”

Anonymous@5:16 p.m. replied: “I started with Gannett in 1987 and in 1988 the publisher ‘retired’ — wink, wink. I know of at least five Gannett publishers who retired like that. These are people I actually know, who told me it was a retire/resign or we fire you — and here are some benefits to make you go away. There are many more I suspect; all corporations do this with top executives.”

Please post your replies in the comments section, below. To e-mail confidentially, write gannettblog[at]gmail[dot-com]; see Tipsters Anonymous Policy in the green sidebar, upper right.

[Photo: Star-Gazette]

Detroit: Only 116 volunteers for 150 buyouts

Raising the specter of layoffs, the Detroit Free Press and two sister operations fell well short of their target to reduce employment by 150, according to memos sent yesterday by senior executives. The buyouts, among the biggest by any Gannett business, originally came with a starkly worded warning about possible layoffs if there weren’t enough volunteers by the July 18 deadline — last Friday.

The Gannett-owned Freep, plus The Detroit News and the joint operating agency publishing both papers, first appealed for volunteers in late June. At the time, CEO Dave Hunke warned that “the environment in which newspapers operate continues to worsen rapidly.” His June 23 note also said: “If the voluntary offer doesn’t result in a sufficient number of volunteers, or if in the future, economic conditions worsen, it may be necessary to consider layoffs.”

Yesterday’s memos did not mention involuntary layoffs. Also, the memos reported conflicting totals on the number of volunteers, and did not give a complete breakdown of where the buyouts were falling by department. Human resources chief Kristi Bowden of the Detroit Media Partnership said 116 volunteers had offered to be voluntarily laid off. (The joint operating agreement partnership publishes the Freep and the formerly Gannett-owned Detroit News.) News Publisher Jon Wolman cited 115 volunteers. Both memos said all buyout applications had been accepted.

There are plenty of other questions, too: “What are the terms of the buyout? What are they offering?” a reader asks in a new comment, below.

I’ve e-mailed Bowden, asking if layoffs are now being planned.

Wolman said 11 of the 115 applications came from the News. Bowden’s memo didn’t say how the other applications were divided among the Freep and the Detroit Media Partnership’s executive staff. (Gannett sold the News three years ago to MediaNews Group as part of a complicated deal that included Knight Ridder papers.)

Buyouts amid rapid retrenchment
In his memo, Wolman said the buyouts come as the news industry overall shrinks to contend with a worsening economy. “Even so,” he wrote, “the public’s appetite for news content is enormous and growing, and we will reorganize our efforts here to maintain strong coverage. Even with a smaller staff size, I’m confident we can develop innovations that drive our coverage even higher than it is today.”

Last week alone across Gannett:

• The News-Press in Fort Myers, Fla., laid off 36 and eliminated 10 unfilled jobs.
• Three Central New York papers cut about 10 jobs in a consolidation of ad sales and online operations.
• The Arizona Republic offered a second round of buyouts.
• The Honolulu Advertiser laid off 54.

In Detroit, eligible staff were active, benefit-eligible employees who were at least 45 years old, with 10 years’ service as of Friday, July 18.

Is your Gannett paper, TV station or other business cutting staff through buyouts or layoffs? Please post your replies — along with relevant memos — in the comments section, below. To e-mail confidentially, write gannettblog[at]gmail[dot-com]; see Tipsters Anonymous Policy in the green sidebar, upper right.

Earlier: My advice on why you should take a Gannett buyout. Plus: Next buyouts won’t be so generous

[Image: today’s Freep, Newseum]

Three N.Y. papers consolidate online, ad sales

Gannett’s cost cutting spread yesterday to central New York, where newspapers eliminated top management and other jobs in a reorganization of online operations and advertising sales. The papers are the Press & Sun-Bulletin in Binghamton, The Ithaca Journal, and founder Frank Gannett‘s first title — the Star-Gazette in Elmira.

The Central New York Group’s shifts follow a second round of buyouts this week at The Arizona Republic, and layoffs at The Honolulu Advertiser, amid a steep plunge in Gannett’s second-quarter profits.

Binghamton Publisher Sherman Bodner didn’t disclose the exact number of jobs cut in the e-mail he sent to staff about 5 p.m. “The economic climate for our industry remains challenging, and we continue to explore changes that provide economic or strategic advantages,” Bodner said. “We made staffing reductions in our information centers, in our building/facilities departments and in information technology.These were difficult choices, made only after close consideration of other options.”

His e-mail says one manager will now be in charge of the three papers’ online operations, and the number of online-only staff is being reduced, and based at Binghamton. Also, ad sales at the three papers will now be run by a single sales director, Bodner’s note says.

Together, the three papers employ fewer than 800 workers.

Job cuts at your GCI business? Please post a note in the comments section, below. To e-mail confidentially, write gannettblog[at]gmail[dot-com]; see Tipsters Anonymous Policy in the green sidebar, upper right.

[Image: today’s Press & Sun Bulletin, Newseum]

Commentz Korner: ‘Nice to have standards,’ but…

. . . when Hairspray star Ricki Lake is pitted against journalist Tim Russert, standards change big-time! Ithaca Journal Publisher Monte Trammer says he’s seen some negative reaction in the year since the paper started letting readers leave anonymous online comments on stories through Gannett’s StoryChat feature.

But Trammer, who also is publisher of the Star-Gazette in Elmira, N.Y., says readers treat StoryChat for what it is: unedited, unverified postings, mostly by anonymous users. “It’s nice to have standards, and we all do, but once we decide that we’re going to allow the public a voice, we have to allow the public its voice,” he tells the Journal.

Trammer compares StoryChat vs. the print paper to the Ricki Lake Show vs. Meet the Press, hosted by journalist Russert. “The fact that the Ricki Lake Show is not like Meet the Press doesn’t mean we shouldn’t have the Ricki Lake Show,” he says. “It just means that if we’re gonna tune in, we shouldn’t go to Ricki Lake expecting Meet the Press. We go to Ricki Lake and we get what it is. And that’s where we have to be with StoryChat.”

Got an offensive or just-plain-crazy comment that made it past your Gannett site’s filters? Use this link to e-mail Commentz Korner suggestions. See Tipsters Anonymous Policy in the sidebar, upper right. Or leave a note in the moderated comments section, below.

[Images: Russert, NBC; Lake, Flickr member blackmothra. Hat tip, Romenesko]